ACT I: ARRIVAL & THE PERFORMANCE.
They invited me to Santa Monica, to the clean, well-lighted prison of culture called The Broad Stage. The mission: to bear witness to a “subsidized art opera,” a thing of fair quality and certain protection. A fortress against the market. A mausoleum with a liquor license. I went armed with skepticism and a quart of Wild Turkey, sensing the kind of soft, bloodless crime that happens in places where the carpets are thick and the applause is pre-ordained.
This was no starving artist’s garret. This was a 600-seat cathedral of subsidized sanctimony, bankrolled by the gentle, tan, and tastefully wealthy ghosts of Pacific Palisades. A place where failure is impossible because the ledgers are softened by donations, where the only “market” is the whims of board members who understand tax write-offs better than they understand tremolo.
The opera itself was a harmless beast—pleasant voices, inoffensive staging, a story of forgotten anguish that left no stain on the soul. Competent. A pleasant ghost of passion, performed by souls who seemed to believe in the notes, if not the reason for singing them in this particular velvet-lined tomb. It was art protected from the market, which is to say, art protected from life. It had the fair quality of a beautifully preserved specimen under glass. No danger of a heartbeat.
I had come to review a performance. I was about to stumble into an autopsy of a cultural lie.
ACT II: DESCENT INTO THE BOWELS
At intermission I switched to tequila. The Wild Turkey had done its job of getting me through Act I, but what I was seeing—what I was feeling in this place—required something with more venom. I needed to move, to escape the polite murmur of the lobby, so I wandered, following the institutional logic of the building downward, always downward, toward where the real work happens.
I found them in the concrete bowels during what they called “half-hour”—that strange liminal time before the second act when the machinery of theater shows its guts. The carpets ended. The beige warmth gave way to cinder block and industrial lighting. This was the sub-basement, the working spaces, where the moving shadows lived.
A lighting tech named Vince with eyes like shattered cathode rays was coiling cable with the kind of weary precision that comes from doing a thing a thousand times for a thousand different shows. Beside him, a fly-rail operator named Jeannie was checking line sets, her hands moving through the routine but trembling slightly—not from fatigue, but from something else. A kind of institutional sublimation.
They were professionals. The best you could get for the wage of a serf and the promise of nothing.
“You work here often?” I asked, the tequila making me blunt as a hammer.
Vince smiled a thin, joyless smile. “This show? Once. Last show? Once. Next show?” He shrugged, the cable falling into perfect coils despite his casual tone. “They like to… rotate the blessings.”
The phrase hung in the concrete air like a curse disguised as corporate-speak.
Jeannie wouldn’t look at me. “It’s a great house,” she muttered to her own shoes, to the floor, to anyone but the stranger asking questions. “A real privilege.”
They were lobotomized, but not by nature—by design.
In Hollywood, a few miles and a psychic universe away, crews are tribes. They are sticky, loyal, brutal, and professional. A gaffer hires a best boy because he knows the man won’t set the star on fire. A key grip brings back the same rigging team because they’ve worked together through enough disasters to communicate in grunts and hand signals. It’s a mercenary continuity, born of real risk and real money. They build bridges for each other. They remember. They form lineages. The machine, for all its greed and brutality, has a memory.
But here, in this subsidized sanctuary, I was witnessing the Great Cultural Amnesia in action.
These institutions—the opera, the classical series, the serious theater swimming in donor cash—function on a perverse moral economy. They claim to be protectors of the fragile arts from the savage market. Bullshit. They are risk-insulated principalities where the only audience that matters is the Board of Directors. The feedback loop is severed. Quality isn’t tested by bums in seats, but by nods in the donor lounge and the gentle hum of foundation checks clearing.
And with no market discipline, the relationship with labor curdles into something soft and vicious.
Continuity becomes a threat. A crew that remembers last season is a crew that can compare, that can question, that can say, “This is wrong.” Memory is leverage. Leverage is power. And power cannot be allowed to accumulate among the moving shadows.
So they churn them. They burn them out and hire fresh, grateful faces. They speak of “new opportunities” and “broadening the pool” and “giving chances”—language that sounds humane but functions as systemic erasure of experience. They deny bridges. A bridge, in this low-pay hellscape, is the only real currency—the promise of future work for present loyalty. To deny it is to say: Your experience here is a liability. Your growing knowledge is a threat. You will remain forever junior, forever disposable, forever grateful for the “privilege.”
It is a quiet, brutal betrayal. And it is policy.
I looked at Vince’s hands, skilled hands that had run a thousand lighting cues, and knew they would not be invited back. I looked at Jeannie’s face, trying so hard to believe this was normal, this was fine, this was how it should be, and I wanted to scream.
But the tequila was doing the screaming for me, inside my skull, and I needed air.
ACT III: ASCENT TO THE DONOR LOUNGE
I made my way back upstairs, following the sound of cultured laughter and the clink of wine glasses. The donor lounge sat above the theater like a capitalist’s vision of heaven—all soft lighting and expensive cheese and conversations about the “vital sustenance of the form.”
The high culture LARPers were in full plumage. Men in linen jackets discussing tonality and tradition with the confidence of people who’ve never had to choose between health insurance and groceries. Women whose jewelry cost more than Vince and Jeannie’s combined annual income. They were subsidizing a corpse and calling it patronage. They believed, with terrifying sincerity, that they were protecting something sacred from the rabble.
All they were protecting was their own echo.
And here’s the delicious contradiction at the heart of it all, the thing that hit me like a mescaline flashback in that perfumed air: These donors made their fortunes in the most ruthless capitalist machinery ever devised—tech monopolies, real estate speculation, hedge fund alchemy—and now they gather in their beige temple to protect classical music from the very market forces that bought them their third homes.
It’s socialism for the symphony, red in tooth and claw capitalism for everyone else.
They’ll bankroll a full season of Mahler while their investment portfolios feast on gig workers and collapsed pension funds, then pat themselves on the back for saving civilization from commercialization. But let’s be honest about what terrifies them: not that the market will kill Mozart, but that actual economic redistribution might turn Santa Monica into Moscow circa 1917-1931. They want the Bolshoi’s prestige without the Bolsheviks’ economic program. They’ll subsidize the arts with the loose change from exploitation, call it philanthropy, and sleep like babies in their ocean-view bunkers.
The revolution will be funded—as long as it stays in the orchestra pit and never, ever reaches the parking lot where the Teslas wait, gleaming and unrepentant.
These places have deep pockets for Steinway pianos and hydraulic stages, for commissioned works and visiting artists, but not for career ladders. Not for the people who actually make the magic happen. They understand the depreciation schedule of a lighting board, but not of a human soul. They will protect jazz from corporate consolidation and classical music from reality TV—worthy goals, in a sane world—but they will feed the very people who build the stage for their dreams into a woodchipper of permanent precarity.
The irony is savage enough to make a hyena weep: The big, bad, industrial film machine—that brutal, profit-driven, soulless Hollywood apparatus—treats its foot soldiers with more professional respect than these humane, non-profit sanctuaries of high art.
I needed to get out of there. The perfume was choking me. The laughter was like ice picks in my ears. I stumbled toward what I thought was the exit.
I was wrong.
ACT IV: THE PHANTOM’S REVELATION
I got lost somewhere between the donor lounge and what I desperately hoped was a bathroom, which should tell you everything about my condition. The tequila had reached that critical stage where doorways become suggestions and hallways multiply like cells under a microscope. I was looking for an exit—any exit—and instead I found a service corridor leading down.
Always down in these places. The truth is always in the basement.
This wasn’t the working basement where I’d found Vince and Jeannie. This was deeper. Older. A maintenance corridor that predated the renovations, before the donors had sanitized it into their cultural theme park.
The stairwell was concrete and brutal. My footsteps echoed wrong—not like a man descending stairs, but like something older, some pattern laid down in the architecture itself. The air got colder. The lights flickered with ancient, deferred-maintenance uncertainty. And somewhere in the mechanical depths, I could hear it: not music, but the memory of music. The ghost of passion that once lived here.
Past darkened prop rooms. Past costume shops where mannequins stood like witnesses to crimes they couldn’t name. Past lighting storage where old instruments hung like mechanical bats. Past coiled cable and ancient rigging and all the guts of theatrical illusion.
The walls were sweating. Or I was sweating. Or the building itself was sweating out some institutional fever dream.
And then I felt it. A presence. Not hostile, but aware. Watching. Judging.
The Phantom.
Not the sanitized touring production version. The original. The pissed-off, unsubsidized artist who lived in the bones of the theater itself. The one who demanded perfection with a knife at your throat. The one who cared with a violent, unmarketable passion that couldn’t be contained in quarterly reports or donor presentations.
He didn’t appear—this wasn’t that kind of drunk. But I understood him, suddenly and completely. The knowledge came like a download, dispensed directly into my skull by the building itself:
Watch, the Phantom whispered from the walls. Watch the bullet fly back into the gun.
And I saw it:
These donors built their fortunes dismantling the post-war social contract. Gig economies. Automation. Hedge funds treating pension funds like piñatas. Real estate speculation turning housing into asset class for LinkedIn ghouls with MBAs and cocaine habits.
They turbocharged capitalism, stripped it for parts, sold the scrap metal, burned down the factory and pissed on the ashes. Got obscenely, criminally rich.
This created a world where the middle class—the people who once bought season tickets—now work three jobs to afford rent two hours from anything resembling culture. They’re too busy driving for Uber between warehouse shifts to give a damn about Bartók.
The entire ecosystem that could sustain art on its own merit has been systematically destroyed, strip-mined, converted into quarterly dividends.
And then—this is where the Phantom’s laughter started, echoing like broken glass in a blender—the same people who burned down the economic forest step forward as saviors.
They are the arsonist and the fire department. The disease and the cure. The pusher and the rehab clinic. And they demand praise for both roles.
The protection racket in its purest form. The mob boss burns down every shop, then offers to “protect” the last one—for a fee, with conditions about how you operate, who you hire, when you smile and say “thank you.”
Because they’ve destroyed every other funding mechanism, they become the only game in town. Total control.
They don’t just fund the art—they own it. They decide what’s “worthy.” The art becomes a private garden reflecting their tastes, their desperate need for tax-deductible cultural legitimacy.
It’s a trophy room. A museum of their own virtue. A mausoleum with their names on it.
Then the Phantom showed me the faces. Vince and Jeannie, and behind them, layered like transparencies, all the other crews cycled through over the years. Ghosts layered on ghosts, sacrificed to the great god of Institutional Amnesia.
And then the Phantom’s rage hit me like a physical wave:
He didn’t want a grant. He wanted to burn. He wanted perfection so terrible and beautiful it would consume everyone involved. He would have enslaved his crew to a vision that branded their names into the walls. That’s what real patronage cost. That’s what real art demanded.
This sanitized, risk-free, crew-cycling mockery? It would have driven him to murder.
They’re LARPing. Playing dress-up as patrons. They want the Medici aesthetic without the Medici commitment. They want their name on a building and a tax write-off. They want to feel cultured without the mess. Without the risk. Without anyone ever telling them ‘no’ or demanding they actually sacrifice anything that matters.
They’ve built a system where the arts come to them, hat in hand, and accept whatever terms are offered. You want to stage your opera? Fine. On our terms. With our people. With our aesthetic. And you’ll smile while you do it.
They sleep soundly believing they’re heroes of civilization. That their check makes them Medici. That their name on a building equals giving a shit about the people who make the art possible.
When really they’re running a company town. The steel baron builds a library while his workers die of lung disease. Carnegie. Rockefeller. The whole rotten lineage.
The market they “protect” us from is the market they built. The brutality they shield us from is their own creation.
It’s protection, all right. The kind with a broken nose and a weekly envelope. The kind where you thank the man who burned down your neighborhood for offering to rebuild it—on his terms, in his image, with his name on every brick.
And then he was gone. The presence lifted. The cold remained, but the awareness, the judgment, the terrible clarity—evaporated like steam.
I was alone in a maintenance corridor, drunk and shaking, with knowledge I hadn’t asked for burning a hole in my skull.
ACT V: ESCAPE & THE NIGHT
I found my way back to the surface somehow, stumbling through corridors that suddenly made sense again, following the sound of the orchestra tuning for Act II. I emerged into the lobby like a deep-sea diver breaking the surface, gasping for air that didn’t taste like concrete and ancient rage.
The donors were filing back into the theater, refreshed from their intermission wines and their conversations about sustaining the form. They couldn’t see what I’d seen. They didn’t know what the Phantom knew. They would never know.
I made it as far as the lobby before I had to stop, had to lean against a wall, had to process what had just happened in that basement corridor.
Because here’s the thing the Phantom had made me understand, the thing that made the whole savage joke complete:
I don’t believe the market will protect Bartók any more than it will protect your average Joe. Left to pure bonfire of vanities, we’d have nothing but Spider-Man sequels and Taylor Swift on infinite loop until the heat death of the universe. The market, unrestrained, is a savage beast that will cheerfully devour anything that doesn’t turn a profit by Tuesday. String quartets, experimental theater, difficult poetry, the entire avant-garde—all would be ground into dust under the wheels of algorithmic optimization and quarterly earnings reports.
So yes, we need protection. Yes, we probabl need subsidy. Yes, someone has to stand between Shostakovich and the focus groups, between Beckett and the market research departments.
But here’s the rub, here’s the thing that makes it all so perfectly, viciously American:
If you’re going to play socialist protector of the fragile and beautiful, you don’t get to do it with one hand while the other hand is strangling the people who actually make the art. You don’t get to cosplay as the Medicis while running a labor model that would make a Victorian mill owner blush. Either you believe in protecting people from market brutality, or you don’t. Either you think human beings deserve dignity and continuity and fair compensation for skilled work, or you think they’re disposable widgets to be cycled through your cultural monument like so much Kleenex.
You can’t have socialism for Stravinsky and feudalism for stagehands.
Well, you can—that’s exactly what they’ve built—but don’t expect anyone with a functioning bullshit detector to call it noble.
The lights were dimming for Act II. I needed to get out. I needed air. I needed to never come back to this place.
I fled before the final curtain, the tequila and the metaphysical decay and the Phantom’s downloaded knowledge fighting a war in my gut. Outside, the Santa Monica night was cool and false, the kind of California perfect that feels like a movie set, like something designed by committee to offend no one and inspire nothing.
I thought of the crew in there, striking the set of a beautiful, protected, amnesiac lie after the performance ended. Vince would coil his cables with professional precision. Jeannie would check her line sets one last time. They would do excellent work because they were excellent professionals.
And they would not be invited back. They were already ghosts.
The art was safe. The artists were funded. The humans who built the stage for their dreams were being ushered out the service entrance, into the warm California night, where they would vanish without a trace.
They had exorcised the Phantom and kept the chandelier. A fair swap for the donors. A death sentence for the soul.
You can fund the orchestra, you can buy the Steinway, you can rotate the crew until they’re all anonymous and grateful and disposable, but you cannot purchase the Phantom.
The Phantom is the unsubsidized truth. He is the one who refuses to pay the protection fee. He is the violent, beautiful, unmarketable passion that demands excellence at the cost of comfort. He doesn’t want a tax deduction; he wants perfection that burns.
And that is why the theater felt so cold, even in the warm Santa Monica night. It wasn’t just the air conditioning or the tequila or my deteriorating mental state. It was the fact that the Phantom had finally left the building. He looked at the Teslas in the parking lot, he looked at the “rotated” crew of disposables, he looked at the high-culture LARPers in their linen jackets discussing the vital sustenance of the form, and he realized there was nothing left here worth haunting.
God help us all.
Leave a Reply